I was reading Napoleon Hill’s book, The Law of Success, this morning. In the chapter entitled “Accurate Thought,” he says the following:
To think accurately you must separate facts from mere information. There is much information available to you that is not based upon facts. Second, you must separate facts into two classes; namely the important and the unimportant, or the relevant and the irrelevant.
Only by doing this can one think clearly.
This book was written in 1928. I wonder what Mr. Hill would think of Facebook?
I have just finished reading the Radius+ 2026 Self-Storage Industry Annual Forecast, and boy, did that sentence seem relevant. So I re-read it and let me share with you what I deem as relevant facts, and hopefully my clear thinking on what it means for those of us smaller investors in the self-storage industry for the upcoming year or so.
One thing I like about Radius+ is it produces one of the more data-driven, independent reports in our industry, meaning no sponsorships, no promotional influence, just their numbers and what they think they mean.
I do not necessarily think all their numbers are correct (remember they primarily scrape website information) or agree with every assumption they say the numbers mean, but a lot of what they found confirms what I have been thinking for a while, and some of it surprised me.
Let me walk you through it as “clearly” as I can.
The Demand Picture Is Worst in Modern Industry History
Radius+ does not mince words about the past few years.
They call this the longest and deepest demand contraction in the modern history of self-storage. That is a significant statement from a data platform that has been tracking this industry for years.
The two engines that drive storage demand, employment growth and existing home sales, slowed at the same time and stayed slow. That double slowdown has never happened before at this duration. In prior cycles, one offset the other. This time, both retreated together.
The housing piece is the biggest story. Most homeowners are locked into mortgages near 3%, financed during the low-rate years through 2021. Moving to an equivalent home today could cost them 50 to 100% more per month. So they are not moving. And when people do not move, they do not rent storage. It is that simple, according to Radius+.
The Fed has cut rates three times and brought the federal funds rate down to roughly 3.50–3.75% by December 2025. But the structural lock-in of those low-rate mortgages is not going away quickly. The housing market will stay constrained until affordability genuinely improves.
I see nothing on the horizon that is going to change this.
However, this may not be a contradiction of my last episode of my interpretation of the REIT reports from Q3.
Radius+ believes demand has bottomed and has little room to deteriorate further. Web rate growth is showing signs of recovery heading into 2027. I think they are right.
The Supply Picture Is the Best News in the Report
New facility deliveries are expected to drop below 500 in 2026. That is a 70% decline from the peak of 1,532 deliveries in 2023, and the lowest level since the industry climbed out of the 2009 recession.
Construction is being killed by high costs, tight lending, and projects that simply do not pencil anymore. Construction spending peaked above $640 million per month in late 2023 and has been falling ever since. As of late 2025, only 396 facilities were actively under construction nationally.
This matters enormously for existing operators. Fewer new facilities coming online means the market will absorb existing inventory faster when demand returns. The report suggests the supply correction will persist through at least 2027 due to the 18- to 24-month lead time on new projects.
The faucet is essentially off. That is good news for those of us already in the game.
A Big Warning for Suburban Multi-Story Developers
This section of the report should be required reading for anyone thinking about building a large, multi-story, climate-controlled facility in a suburban market.
Stop!
If you have millions of dollars to move out the door, why not? Right?
Not in suburbs unless you want problems.
This strategy initially evolved in dense urban environments. Vertical, multi-story, climate-controlled buildings made sense there. Land cost high and small along with unmet demand.
But applying it to suburban markets?
The reason is irrelevant. It could be rising land cost or just greed (deal with the oversupply problem or the lease-up problem later), this is an extremely troubled sector of our industry.
The problem is that suburban customers do not behave like urban ones.
The data point that stopped me cold: non-first-floor rates in suburban markets are now 12% below pre-pandemic levels. Upper-floor units in suburban multi-story buildings are struggling badly, and the price spread between first-floor and upper-floor units is nearly double what it is in urban markets.
Just stop it unless you want us or someone else to buy it at a severe discount when you fail.
Suburban customers want drive-up access, ground-floor convenience, and speed. They do not want elevators. When you force them upstairs, you create a product mismatch and the market is telling you that in the rent data.
One lender in the report summed it up plainly:
“Multi-story, climate-controlled facilities in suburban areas have struggled the most, as customers generally prefer not to go upstairs or rely on elevators.”
If you are a smaller operator with a more traditional mix of drive-up and climate-controlled ground-floor units, this is actually good news for you. The product you have is what suburban customers want.
At most on tight suburban sites with demand two-story fabricated systems. But only with clearly proven demand from a good feasibility report.
Sellers… The Acquisition Is Still Frozen
Transaction volume has fallen sharply from the 2021 peak and remains depressed. The core problem is a wide bid-ask gap that has not closed.
Sellers… those blow-and-go days are gone!
Most sellers (or perhaps their agents) are anchored to peak pricing from 2020 to 2022, when cap rates were trading in the mid-4% to low-5% range.
Sellers… 6% cap rates are in most cases still too low.
Buyers need materially lower values to make deals work at today’s debt costs. As one acquisitions professional in the report put it:
“Everyone is waiting for the reset. Sellers still want peak pricing, and buyers cannot get there with current debt.”
Sellers with low-rate legacy loans have almost no incentive to sell. Why trade a 3.5% loan for today’s environment? The report does note a slight uptick in 2025 acquisition activity, suggesting the market is beginning to thaw but slowly. It is most likely that sellers’ legacy loans ending and being forced to refinance accounted for a slight uptick from those owners who didn’t like the prospects of severely reduced cash flows their new loans would result in. That may have driven the slight increase in that year.
My take is patient money is exactly what this environment rewards. If you can hold, hold. If you are buying, be conservative on your underwriting and do not expect the seller to meet you at a rational number without some patience of your own.
And of course work to find off-market deals.
The Industry Is Consolidating — Just Not How You Think
Here is something I think I am beginning to understand. The industry is consolidating, but it is not happening primarily through acquisitions. It is happening through third-party management.
Ten years ago, third-party management represented less than 2% of all storage facilities. Today it is approaching 10%. Extra Space now manages over 2,200 facilities it does not own. CubeSmart manages over 860. I talked about it in last week’s episode.
These platforms are expanding rapidly, and they are bringing REIT-level revenue management and marketing to facilities that compete directly with independent operators.
Of the 66,241 storage facilities in the United States, 49,500 are still owned by small private companies. The industry remains deeply fragmented at the ownership level. But at the operational level, consolidation is happening fast.
I have said this before and I will say it again: the REITs are not just competing with you on price. They are competing with you on data, systems, and speed. That is a fight you can win, but only if you are intentional about it. AI is leveling the field in my opinion, but as small owners we must embrace it or be left in the cold.
Nothing Has Changed Here — Market Data Tells Us Everything Is Local
The Top 25 performing markets in the Radius+ ranking share one trait: they have limited new supply. San Jose, Omaha, Portland, Buffalo, Pittsburgh, and Minneapolis are among the leaders. These markets have tighter fundamentals because disciplined development (or high barriers to entry) protected them from the overbuilding that crushed other markets.
The bottom 25 markets are almost universally places that absorbed a wave of new multi-story supply in a compressed timeframe (again…stop it). They are still working through lease-up and will be for a while.
The consistent message from this report is national averages are increasingly meaningless. Performance in this cycle is being driven market by market, trade area by trade area. That is exactly what I have been saying for years, and it is exactly why we need to know our trade areas inside and out.
The Quote That Sums It All Up
Chris Berg of Abernathey Development said it best in the report: “The next cycle won’t be led by whoever builds the most, it will be led by those who build the smartest.”
That applies to operators too, not just developers. The operators who come out of this cycle ahead will be the ones who knew their markets, ran disciplined operations, did not chase bad deals, and positioned themselves to act when the moment came.
Based on everything in this report, and what I can see, if I am thinking clearly, that moment is getting closer.



0 Comments